Site icon Montgomery County Counseling Center

GTA 6: Does the Realism Matter More Than the Rating?

The release of Grand Theft Auto 6 is here. It has been one of the most anticipated video game releases ever. Yet back when GTA5 came out, parents were asking the question “should I let my teenager play it?” And here we are, more than 13 years later, still asking this same question.

This blog is actually NOT about the question “should I let my kid play GTA6”.

There are plenty of arguments on both sides. On one hand, many teens are able to reasonably distinguish between fiction and reality; they understand that the adult themes they’re allowed to experience in a game format are discernibly different from what is acceptable in real life. And after all, GTA 6 is going to be a major part of the conversation. Those who are not allowed to play may feel left out. And feeling “other than” is no minor emotion. On the other hand, there are valid concerns about the intensity of such mature themes and whether they are suitable or appropriate for minors.

Accordingly, most blogs and articles will take a similar approach to advice: Consider your child’s age, maturity, emotional development, and ability to distinguish fantasy from reality. Think about screen time, sleep, school, and other responsibilities. All of that makes sense and you don’t need me to tell you that.

As a therapist, however, I find myself wondering whether we are even asking the right question. I think what we need to grapple with is much greater than any one family’s choice.

What happens when video game technology gets so realistic that it begins to cross a psychological and moral boundary?  

Games where you shoot people are not new (though even that puts GTA 6 mildly- it’s mature themes expand far beyond gun violence alone). Before this, there was Call of Duty, GTA Vice City, and many more… all games that many current parents grew up playing. I played them too. 

But something about GTA6 is different. 

Think about an older game like GoldenEye on N64 (really aging myself here). When the graphics were limited by the technology of late 90s, characters looked like collections of pixels. The environments were obviously fake and even when you were shooting a “human figure”, there was a layer of fantasy between you and what was happening on the screen. This was even true of the earlier Grand Theft Auto game release 13 years ago. Even amidst the intensity of the violence (and even though it was praised for its realism of the time), GTA5 was still unmistakably a video game.

Technology has changed the level of realism that GTA6 brings.

GTA 6 creates an extraordinarily detailed world. The people look like real people. Their movements look like real human movements. The environments look like places that actually exist. And the violence that is represented has a new level of visual detail and realism that previous generations of video games simply could not have achieved. And therein lies the moral boundary.

The more important questions I think we should be asking.

As technology gets better at reproducing reality, where is the line? When does “it’s just a game” become a less satisfying justification for what a player actually experiences? Even if a teenager can intellectually grasp that the game isn’t real, that doesn’t mean the experience is inconsequential. Case in point, we know horror movies are fictional. But that doesn’t prevent many from being disturbed by them. The fact that something is simulated does not necessarily make the experience emotionally or psychologically harmless to the minds and nervous systems of our precious mini-humans (and adults for that matter too).

Maybe the realism doesn’t matter very much… or maybe it does? Let’s take “mature themes” out of it all. We can all probably agree that there is a huge difference between the experience of flying a plane on a GameBoy and sitting inside Delta’s flight simulator. The distinction is so profound that the latter is not just used for fun but for training real pilots to develop real skills. 

So as video games become more and more realistic, is it possible that we are not just exposing our children to the content, but actually training them on it? Even when cognitive discernment between fantasy and reality is sound, is the magnitude of impact on nervous systems  mitigatable? Do our assumptions about the risks (or lack thereof) about simulated video games need to evolve just as much as technology has? And who is responsible for determining the answers?

My prediction (and my hope) about the conversation surrounding GTA6

I know I certainly don’t have all the answers! But I do have a prediction… which is that these very legitimate questions are going to emerge eventually. Right now, the dominant conversation is excitement; GTA 6 is a pop-culture event that some have been waiting years for. But I predict the day will come when folks notice a real growing discomfort with how hyper-realistic the game is. And, as is often the case with everything in race between mental health and technology, I fear it will likely be more reactionary than preventative. Heck even writing this article on the day of the GTA6 release is late to the game, no? (pun intended)

What do you think?

We’d love to hear where you land on this. Share your thoughts in the comments or shoot us an email. And if this conversation is stirring things up in your home, you know we’re always here!


About the Author

Alex Bleiweis, LCSW-C, is a licensed therapist and Assistant Executive Director at Montgomery County Counseling Center in Rockville, MD. He earned his Master’s in Social Work from the University of Maryland School of Social Work. Alex uses a practical, skills-based approach rooted in Cognitive Behavioral Therapy (CBT) to help clients create meaningful, lasting change. He specializes in working with young adults and professionals facing career challenges, as well as individuals struggling with process addictions like gambling and technology overuse.


Join Our Mailing List

Exit mobile version